English Notes Latest Questions

Discuss the two opposing views on nature as depicted in the poem Ecology

Discuss the two opposing views on nature as depicted in the poem Ecology

2 Answers

  1. Following are the two opposing views in the poem Ecology:

    1. Protection of the Champak tree or nature by the mother of the poet.
    2. Cutting of the Champak tree by the poet.

    Ecology Poem Summary

  2. The poem “Ecology” presents two opposing views on nature, showcasing a conflict between the son and the mother regarding the Red Champak tree in their garden.

    The son’s perspective highlights the negative aspects of nature. He observes how the tree’s pollen causes his mother to suffer from severe migraines, with the fragrance being suffocating and pervasive. He sees the tree as a source of discomfort and believes that cutting it down would alleviate his mother’s pain. From his viewpoint, nature is portrayed as something to be controlled and modified for the well-being of humans.

    On the other hand, the mother holds a contrasting view, emphasizing the positive aspects of nature. She values the tree for its age and the fortuitous fertilization it received from a passing bird. It holds significance for her as a symbol of good fortune, providing abundant flowers for religious offerings to the gods and future generations of their family. The mother sees the tree as a valuable part of their heritage and is willing to endure the migraines as a trade-off for its benefits. From her perspective, nature is cherished and respected, even with its inherent challenges.

    These opposing views reflect a tension between the practical and emotional aspects of nature. The son’s approach is more pragmatic, seeking to prioritize human comfort and well-being. In contrast, the mother’s perspective encompasses a deeper connection to the tree, rooted in tradition, symbolism, and a willingness to accept the drawbacks nature presents.

    Ultimately, the poem raises questions about our relationship with nature and how we navigate the conflicting aspects it may present. It encourages readers to consider different viewpoints and the complexities of our interactions with the natural world.

You must login to add an answer.